keeping a grip
Tuesday, December 20th, 2005I was skimming through Judge John Jones’ opinion on Kitzmiller vs. The Dover Area School District, released today. I’ve never actually read a court opinion before, but I was struck by how straightforward it was, and clear-headed. Also by how mercilessly it shreds the defendants’ arguments. I mean, justifiably so — I still can’t believe we’re wasting time and money on this at all. But its tone suggested a bias. Calling the pedagogy implied by some of the Dover board’s decisions “colossally bad” teaching, for example.
Then I read this:
Jones — an appointee of President Bush, who backs the teaching of Intelligent Design — defended his decision in personal terms.
“Those who disagree with our holding will likely mark it as the product of an activist judge. If so, they will have erred as this is manifestly not an activist court,” Jones writes.
All I can say is thank the Designer for rationality. And thank you, Judge Jones, for doing your job.
